Tuesday, November 17, 2026

The cement truck v school bus risk analysis

I've been harping away re the disparity between the hourly wage of school bus drivers compared to cement truck drivers for years.

Usually it comes up in September, when you always hear stories about kids not getting to school, on account the school bus contractors can't find drivers. I've heard those sob-stories  for years, and somewhere along the line, I got to wondering why I've never in my life ever heard of  cement contractors experiencing a driver shortage.

In these parts, some of the bus drivers are unionized, and some are not. Either way, their hourly wage won't be much over $20.  Far as I know, every cement truck driver in the province is unionized. Unita has cement truck drivers, Teamsters too, and some are covered by other contracts, but what they all have in common is every one of them is making at least 50% more for driving cement across town that the school bus driver makes for delivering children to school.

In many jurisdictions that differential rises to multiples of two or three. You'd be hard pressed to find a Teamsters driver delivering cement in Toronto who's not making well into six numbers per year.

And it gets worse, way worse than that!  

The school bus driver is in fact doing two jobs, one underpaid, and the other, supervising the children, completely unpaid! School boards and teacher's unions and the Ministry of Ed all promise you your children will have the supervision of professional educators every moment of the school day... and then the bell rings and up to forty exuberant children, finally freed from adult supervision, make a mad dash for the bus, there to be supervised by the person driving the bus?

I ask you, has any cement truck driver every had to overcome the distraction 40 unruly children represent? NO!  Yet they get two or three times the pay?

I realize I'm a little beyond a prime candidate for union organizer, but I would suggest, at a minimum, school bus drivers achieve wage parity with the cement truck drivers. Furthermore, every bus needs to have a responsible adult aboard whose job it is to supervise the children. And you'd think the organizers would be all over that; twice as many dues coming out of every bus!

Makes perfect sense to me!


No comments:

Post a Comment